Yossarian
Further information: Yossarian
Captain John Yossarian is a fictional character in Joseph Heller's
novel Catch-22 and its sequel Closing Time, and the protagonist of
both books. In Catch-22, Yossarian is a 28-year-old Captain and B-25
bombardier in the 256th Bombardment Squadron of the Army Air Corps,
stationed on the small island of Pianosa off the Italian mainland
during World War II. Yossarian's exploits are based on the experiences
of the author; Heller was also a bombardier in the Air Corps,
stationed on an island off the coast of Italy during World War II.
Chaplain Tappman
Further information: Chaplain A. T. Tappman
Tappman is a naïve Anabaptist minister from Kenosha, Wisconsin, who is
tormented throughout the novel by his rude, manipulative atheist
assistant, Corporal Whitcomb. Easily intimidated by the cruelty of
others, the chaplain is a kind, gentle and sensitive man who worries
constantly about his wife and children at home.
Colonel Cathcart
Further information: Colonel Cathcart
A full colonel, Chuck Cathcart is a group commander at the U.S. Army
Air Corps base in Pianosa and is obsessed with becoming a general. As
such, he does whatever it takes to please his superiors, in
particular, by repeatedly raising the number of missions the men have
to fly to complete a tour of duty beyond that normally required by
other outfits. This becomes the bane of Yossarian's life, as every
time he comes close to obtaining the target number of missions for
being sent home, Colonel Cathcart raises the number again.
Doctor Daneeka
Further information: Doc Daneeka
Dr. Dan Daneeka is the squadron flight surgeon and a friend of the
novel's protagonist, Yossarian. Doc Daneeka's main motivation is for
his own welfare, whether that be making money or protecting his own
life. He generally forgets his moral duty as a physician except in the
most extreme of circumstances. Doc Daneeka feels the military is
responsible for him being drafted into the war effort and putting him
in harm's way, because they were distrustful of him when he lied on
his drafting papers about his health. He is constantly scared of
upsetting his superiors who may see fit to then ship him off to the
far more dangerous South Pacific. Already he sees it as military
cruelty to have been assigned to the Air Corps even though he is
scared of flying.
Milo Minderbinder
Further information: Milo Minderbinder
First Lieutenant Milo Minderbinder is the mess officer at the U.S.
Army Air Corps base and he becomes obsessed with expanding mess
operations and trading goods for the profits of the syndicate (in
which he and everyone else "has a share"). Milo is a satire of the
modern businessman, and beyond that is the living representation of
capitalism, as he has no allegiance to any country, person or
principle unless it pays him and profit is generated. Milo even begins
contracting missions for the Germans, fighting on both sides in the
battle at Orvieto and bombing his own squadron.
Lieutenant Nately
Further information: Nately
Nately's family originally enlisted him to serve in the Air Corps,
believing the war would be over by the time he finished his training
and that he would mingle with "gentlemen." Therefore, Nately could
gain the pride of enlisting without actually having to fight. Instead,
he mingled with Yossarian and Dunbar, and was sent overseas. He lives
in a tent with McWatt next to Havermeyer's tent. His most notable
contribution in the book is his involvement with a whore, "Nately's
Whore," who is for the most part uninterested in him until he saves
her from a sleepless night with generals and so she gets an
opportunity to get some sleep. He is often filled with American
optimism, shown by his desire to marry his whore and send her kid
sister to a respected college in the United States. He is killed on a
mission when Dobbs flies his plane into Nately's. Nately's Whore
blames Yossarian and spends the rest of the book trying to murder him.
Lieutenant Scheisskopf
Further information: Scheisskopf
Scheisskopf is the training unit commander for Yossarian and
Clevinger, and he takes a particular dislike to Clevinger. Even though
Clevinger is just as serious about parades as Scheisskopf, and his
ideas help the squadron win multiple parades, Scheisskopf still
considers him a "wise guy", and someone that needs to be "brought down
a peg or two."
Snowden
Further information: Yossarian
Snowden is a member of Yossarian's flight during a mission, and acts
as catalyst for the fundamental change in Yossarian's mentality and
outlook. After their plane takes heavy anti-aircraft fire, Snowden is
mortally wounded and it is Yossarian who attempts to come to Snowden's
aid by treating his visible wounds with bandages and sulfanilamide
powder. Snowden's death leaves a lasting impression on Yossarian.
Captain Aardvark
Further information: Captain Aardvark
Captain Aardvark (called Aarfy) is the navigator in Yossarian's B-25
bomber (but only when Yossarian is flying in the lead ship - hence
Aarfy's sporadic appearances in the air in the novel). He is oblivious
to incoming flak, repeatedly gets lost on missions, and always smokes
a pipe. He befriends Nately in the hope of working for Nately's
wealthy father after the war. Aarfy sees himself as moral and protects
well-connected women from the sexual advances of other officers, but
he ends up raping and murdering the innocent maid Michaela, and when
asked by Yossarian why he didn't simply hire a prostitute, repeats his
common admonition that "Old Aarfy has never paid for it." He shows no
remorse for these crimes until he begins to worry that he might be
brought to justice for them.
[edit]Other characters
Appleby - A young pilot from Iowa. He is described as being "as good
at shooting craps as he was at playing ping-pong, and he was as good
at playing ping-pong as he was at everything else." Appleby's
character appears to represent those who thrive to a certain extent
within a bureaucratic system and feel threatened by others who do not
play along as much as they would like them to. He follows regulations
without question and does everything he is supposed to do, managing to
succeed with minimal effort at whatever he does.
Captain Black - Because of the lack of risk involved in not flying
missions, Captain Black wanted to take over Major Duluth's position as
squadron commander when the Major was killed over Perugia. He was
thwarted, however, by Major Major, who was appointed squadron
commander as a joke by an I.B.M. machine. Captain Black also
constantly mocks his fellow countrymen at the Pianosa airbase when
they are faced by dangerous missions, by constantly telling everyone
to "eat your liver." Since he is the camp's intelligence officer, he
is not on combat duty and can therefore maintain his gleeful attitude
to the men risking their lives in the air. Black is a paranoid
anti-Communist and pressures all the men to take loyalty oaths, but
out of personal spite prevents Major Major from taking one.
Colonel Cargill - Before the war Cargill was a successful, though
completely untalented, marketing executive. In the Air Force, Colonel
Cargill provided his legendary lack of skills as General Peckem's
troubleshooter. He took self-satisfaction in genius for ineptitude
when addressing the enlisted men instead of the officers.
Clevinger - A highly principled, highly educated man who acts as
Yossarian's foil within the story. His optimistic view of the world
causes Yossarian to consider him to be a "dope," and he and Yossarian
each believe the other is crazy.
Nurse Cramer - Nurse Duckett's best friend. After Nurse Duckett starts
a relationship with Yossarian, puritanical Nurse Cramer stops speaking
to her.
Major Danby - An intellectual college professor with a passive and
somewhat melancholic, yet somewhat serene outlook on life who sees
himself as a poor match for the armed services due to his lack of
aggression. He briefs the airmen on upcoming missions and often acts
as a mediator for disputes between enlisted men and as a confidant to
most of the officers.
Mrs. Daneeka Doc Daneeka's wife. When the doctor is mistakenly
declared dead after listing himself fraudulently on a flight manifest
for a doomed flight, she finds herself suddenly rich and available,
and moves away, leaving no forwarding address.
Further information: Doc Daneeka
Major —— de Coverley - Major —— de Coverley has a terrifying visage in
the Biblical tradition, so much so that men will do his desires
without his even saying a word, and no one dares ask his first name.
The exact nature of the Major's duties within the bomber group is
uncertain. He is Major Major's executive officer, but at the squadron
base in Pianosa his only official duties are pitching horseshoes,
renting two-room apartments for the soldiers on rest leave, and
kidnapping Italian laborers to help around the base. His frequent
appearance during the fall of major cities makes him an object of
interest to intelligence agencies on both sides, neither of which can
identify him.
General Dreedle - The commander of the U.S. Army Air Corps base in
Pianosa, Dreedle is an exceedingly blunt and ill-tempered man. He is
an archetypal no-nonsense military man who does not care what the men
under his command do as long as they fight and die unquestioningly
when given orders. Despite this, he is generally apathetic to the war
effort (having lost all drive after he was made General and he found
he had "nothing more to aim for") and now mostly busies himself with
harassing his son-in-law, Colonel Moodus. His arch-rival is General
Peckem, head of Special Services in Rome; the two men frequently have
their disputes mediated without their knowledge by the desk clerk,
ex-P.F.C. Wintergreen.
Dobbs - Originally a healthy young man, the effects of excessive
combat missions have shot Dobbs' nerves, and when the narration of the
book begins he is emotionally unstable and physically spent. He is
described as being one of the worst pilots in the corps and his
mid-air panic leads him to snatch the controls of the plane away from
Huple, when Snowden is killed. He plots to kill Colonel Cathcart but
will only do it if Yossarian tells him it's a good idea, which
Yossarian never does.
Nurse Duckett - At the start of the novel Nurse Duckett does not like
Yossarian but later on she has a relationship with Yossarian which
jeopardizes her friendship with Nurse Cramer. She breaks off her
affair with Yossarian when she decides to marry a doctor, and realizes
she should not jeopardize her chances by carrying on openly with
Yossarian.
Dunbar - An airman stationed at the same base as Yossarian, on the
island of Pianosa. He and Yossarian seem to have similar
personalities, and so they make fast friends. Like Yossarian, Dunbar's
chief goal is to prolong his life to whatever extent possible, often
by cultivating boredom. He frequently accompanies Yossarian in the
hospital, faking injuries to stay out of combat like his friend does.
Captain Flume - Captain Flume is the squadron's public relations
officer, until he moves out of the trailer he shares with Chief White
Halfoat after Halfoat threatens to slit Flume's throat open from ear
to ear. He spends most of the book living like a hermit in the woods,
which gradually drives him insane.
Giuseppe (the soldier who sees everything twice) - A delirious soldier
who creates a panic in the hospital by shouting, "I see everything
twice!" Yossarian imitates him (by seeing two fingers regardless of
whether a doctor holds up one, two, or none) and later impersonates
him when he dies. The soldier's family does not notice that Yossarian
is not their son.
Gus & Wes - Doc Daneeka's two orderlies, whose main activity is to
paint airmen's gums and toes purple with gentian violet solution.
Daneeka hates them because they refuse to declare him ill so that he
can go home.
Further information: Doc Daneeka
Havermeyer - Havermeyer lives in the tent next to Yossarian's, and
according to Colonel Cathcart he is "the best damn bombardier we've
got." This was because he insists on flying his plane dead straight
to, over, and past the target despite any anti-aircraft fire he
receives. Yossarian despises him because of his insistance in putting
his (Yossarian's) life at stake.
Huple - A fifteen-year-old pilot who lied about his age to get into
the Army, and who shares a tent with Hungry Joe on the wrong side of
the railway tracks. He is shy and nervous but thoroughly idealistic
and patriotic, which is why Yossarian feels sorry for him, feeling
he'll probably die too young. He has a cat that constantly sleeps on
Hungry Joe's face.
Hungry Joe - A fat, perverted soldier who is noted for constantly
trying to photograph women nude, claiming to be a photographer for
Life magazine (which, ironically, he was before the war, although none
of his pictures develop correctly). He is the only pilot who
consistently finished the required number of missions (but was forced
to continue flying as his paperwork was always delayed until the
flight limit was elevated) and has screaming nightmares until he's
ordered back onto combat status.
Sergeant Knight - The turret gunner on Yossarian's plane; he begins a
panic prior to the Bologna operation when he brings extra flak
jackets, causing everyone to think the target is deadly.
Corporal Kolodny - Captain Black's despised assistant. He erroneously
reports that Bologna has been captured by the Allies after Yossarian
surreptitiously redraws the lines on the battle map.
Lieutenant Colonel Korn - Colonel Cathcart's intellectual assistant
and right-hand man. Korn appears along Catchart throughout the novel
and it becomes clear to the reader that Korn does most of the thinking
and most of the work for Cathcart, who only takes the credit. Korn is
portrayed as much more relaxed and less ostentatious than his
superior, but much more sadistic and cynical. Much like Cathcart he
has ambitions for higher military ranks but chooses to be below
Cathcart and remain outside the limelight so that, if something goes
wrong, Cathcart will take the fall instead of him.
Kraft - A man killed at the bombing of a bridge at Ferrara. Yossarian
blames himself, as he ordered the planes back after they missed the
first time.
Luciana - A woman whom Yossarian briefly dates in Rome and whom he
spends a great deal of the second half of the book looking for,
without success.
Major Major Major Major - The squadron commander of the base in
Pianossa, who was named Major Major Major by his father as a joke and
was later made a Major by an IBM machine with a sense of humor similar
to his father's. He is disliked by most of the enlisted men in
Pianossa because he was promoted so suddenly and he chooses to remain
isolated from the other people at the base, letting Sergeant Towser
handle the operations of the base. He doesn't allow people to see him
in his offic while he is in his office, they can only see him when he
isn't there.
Further information: Major Major Major Major
McWatt - The pilot of Yossarian's plane and one of his closest
friends. A young man who appears to be very calm and serene and whom
Yossarian considers to be crazy because he remains sane during the
war. However, he conceals his increasing panic and madness, which
eventually erupts after he accidentally kills Kid Sampson, driving him
to suicide by crashing his plane into a mountain.
Michaela - The half-deaf maid who works in the apartments where
Yossarian and his unit stay while in Rome. She is a sweet and innocent
girl who doesn't speak English and whom the enlisted men mostly leave
alone, except when they mock her in English so she can't understand
them. She represents the innocent bystanders who are hurt by the war,
which makes it even more horrifying when near the end of the book she
is raped and murdered by Aarfy, who simply dismisses the murder as
inconsequential because he's "good old Aarfy, who never pays for it".
Further information: Captain Aardvark
Colonel Moodus - General Dreedle's son-in-law, whom the general hates
and constantly tries to harass and have demoted.
Lieutenant Mudd - More frequently referred to as "the dead man in
Yossarian's tent," Mudd was killed in action before officially joining
the squadron. Due to the bureaucratic uncertainty over the status of
Mudd, no one will accept responsibility for Mudd and his belongings,
and Sergeant Towser refuses to believe the man existed at all.
Orr - A bomber pilot in the squadron who is continually being shot
down and having to crash land in the sea. Described as "a
warm-hearted, simple-minded gnome," Orr is the only person in the
group considered to be crazier than his good friend Yossarian, with
whom he shares a tent. He is declared MIA halfway through the book
after crashing his plane in the Meidterranean but by the end it's
revealed that he had rowed to the netural zone in Sweden to escape the
army, at which point Yossarian realizes that Orr's constant crashes
had been part of his plan. Orr's survival inspires Yossarian to
finally escape the army.
Further information: Orr (Catch-22)
General Peckem - A pompous, pretentious and highly delusional general
who desperately wants to take over General Dreedle's post as the
superior commanding officer of Pianossa. Because of this ambition, he
has a vicious rivalry with Dreedle and constantly tries to undermine
him and have him demoted. His attempts are mostly thwarted without his
knowledge by desk clerk ex-P.F.C. Wintergreen, who enjoys making
Peckem look foolish.
Piltchard & Wren - Two captains in charge of squadron operations that
are always mentioned in tandem. They are sympathetic towards Yossarian
despite his desire to avoid missions.
Corporal Popinjay - The clerk present at Clevinger's trial; he is
imprisoned for being too specific in his shorthand.
Kid Sampson - An underaged soldier killed by the propeller of McWatt's
airplane. The event drives McWatt to suicide and causes Doc Daneeka's
bureaucratic "death".
Major Sanderson - A neurotic psychiatrist who is convinced that
Yossarian is mentally unstable because he acts rationally.
Mrs. Scheisskopf - Scheisskopf is always too busy planning parades to
fulfill his wife's masochistic sexual fantasies. Instead, she sleeps
with Scheisskopf's cadets, so they can all get revenge on her husband.
Further information: Scheisskopf
Sammy Singer - The tailgunner on Yossarian's bomber when Snowden dies.
While he is just a minor character in Catch-22, he becomes one of the
main characters in the sequel, Closing Time.
Corporal Snark - The mess sergeant before Milo Minderbinder. He was
demoted for purposely poisoning sweet potatoes with soap chips, giving
the squadron diarrhea, which he did at Yossarian's request.
Dr. Stubbs
Further information: Doc Daneeka
Sergeant Towser - Major Major's assistant; he prevents anyone from
seeing the Major while he is in his office, and only allows them in
when the Major is gone. Due to Major Major's unwillingness to see
anyone, Towser is the de facto head of the 256th squadron.
Corporal Whitcomb - An atheist who constantly antagonizes and looks to
usurp Chaplain Tappman, his direct superior. By the end of the book,
Tappman manages to gather enough courage to confront Whitcomb and
winds up punching him in the face.
Chief White Halfoat - An American Indian whose family was forced to
move from wherever they settled because oil was always discovered. He
jokingly threatens to slit Catpain Flume's throat while he sleeps,
which accidentally drives Flume to paranoid madness. During the Siege
of Bologna, he decides that he will eventually die of pneumonia, which
he ultimately does.
Ex-P.F.C. Wintergreen - An ex-P.F.C. because of his constant urge to
go AWOL, Wintergreen has been demoted so many times that he entertains
hopes of becoming an ex-general. Due to his position in charge of mail
distribution, he wields a great amount of power in the novel. By
forging documents and destroying mail, he becomes more powerful than
the generals. His main concern throughout the novel is humiliating
General Peckem because he was the first person to have demoted him.
[edit]Unnamed characters
The C.I.D. Investigators
Further information: C.I.D. Investigators
Dreedle's girl Allegedly a nurse, she follows General Dreedle wherever
he goes. She is a very attractive woman and Dreedle keeps her around
to torment his son-in-law, Colonel Moodus, hoping to catch him in an
adulterous situation for which he can punish him.
The maid with the lime-colored panties A woman who Yossarian
paradoxically falls in love with because she is the only woman that
Yossarian can't possibly fall in love with.
Nately's Whore
Further information: Nately
Nately's Whore's Kid Sister
Further information: Nately
The new recruits (Yo-yo's roomies) A group of new young officer-pilots
who Yossarian hates. They are friends from back home, and are excited
to still be able to take part in the war. They practically run
Yossarian out of his tent, and throw out all of Mudd's equipment.
The old man in Rome A 107-year-old man who lives in the brothel
frequented by Nately. He sides with whoever is in power and mocks
Nately's idealism. He reminds Nately uncomfortably of his own father
for the reason that the old man is absolutely nothing like his father.
The Soldier in White An unnamed soldier wrapped completely in
bandages. He is connected to two bottles of unidentified and similar
looking liquid, one which pumps the liquid through an IV into the
soldier, and the other which drains the liquid from the soldier
through a zinc catheter. When the bottles are respectively empty and
full, they are switched around. Dunbar claims there is actually no one
under the bandages.
The Texan An annoying soldier that keeps the men from staying in the
medical ward to hide out from the war.
Wikipedia
Showing posts with label catch-22. Show all posts
Showing posts with label catch-22. Show all posts
Monday, 18 February 2013
List of Catch-22 characters
Labels:
catch-22,
something interesting,
yossarian
Critic's Notebook; Questioning the Provenance of the Iconic 'Catch-22'
When Louis Falstein's ''Face of a Hero'' was published in 1950,
Herbert F. West reviewed it favorably in The New York Times Book
Review, calling it ''the most mature novel about the Air Force that
has yet appeared. . . . a book that is both exciting and important.''
Still, the book and its author faded into obscurity.
When Joseph Heller's ''Catch-22'' was published 11 years later,
Richard G. Stern gave it a negative review in the Times Book Review.
He said that it ''gasps for want of craft and sensibility'' and called
it ''an emotional hodgepodge.'' Despite that indictment, ''Catch-22''
eventually became a phenomenal success -- a best seller, a film and
the cornerstone of a major literary career.
Now, in a strange twist, the two books have come together, and their
meeting has led to a provocative debate. In a recent letter to The
Times of London, Lewis Pollock, a London bibliophile, wondered if
anyone could ''account for the amazing similarity of characters,
personality traits, eccentricities, physical descriptions, personnel
injuries and incidents'' in the two books.
He asked if this were ''a remarkable example of synchronicity.'' That
letter has sparked conjecture in both Britain and the United States
about the origins of ''Catch-22.'' An article appeared this week in
The Sunday Times of London, followed by one the next day on the front
page of The Washington Post suggesting that Mr. Heller may have
appropriated material from Falstein's book.
On the telephone from his home on Long Island, Mr. Heller issued a
categorical denial. He said he was influenced in his writing by
Celine, Waugh and Nabokov, but not by Falstein. ''I never read the
book,'' he said. ''I never heard of the book or the author. To the
extent that there are similarities, they are coincidences, and if the
similarities are striking then they are striking coincidences.''
He added, ''If I went through the 'Iliad' I would probably find as
many similarities to 'Catch-22' as other people seem to be finding
between Falstein's book and mine.''
Robert Gottlieb, who edited ''Catch-22'' for Simon & Schuster, was
astonished at the suggestion that Mr. Heller might have borrowed
anything from Falstein or any other writer. ''I've never seen, heard
or felt Joe Heller doing anything remotely less than honest during our
40-year relationship,'' he said. ''It is inconceivable that he used
any other writer's work. For one thing, he's too shrewd to do
something so blatant. It's easier for me to believe that Falstein
anticipated 'Catch-22.' ''
Both authors were in the Army Air Force in Europe during World War II
as members of combat crews on bombers. Falstein was stationed in
southern Italy, Mr. Heller in Corsica (called Pianosa in his book).
For each, this was a first novel. Mr. Falstein died in 1995 at 86.
While it was easy enough for Mr. Heller to be unaware of Mr.
Falstein's book, it is implausible that Falstein was unaware of
''Catch-22,'' a highly celebrated book that dealt with a closely
related subject. ''Where was Mr. Falstein between 1961 and his
death?'' asked Mr. Gottlieb. ''If he felt his book was misused, he
should have said something about it.'' Falstein's son, Joshua, who is
a court stenographer, said this week that his father never mentioned
''Catch-22'' to him.
From a reading of ''Face of a Hero'' (published by Harcourt Brace and
long out of print), it is clear that each novel stands on its own.
Despite the common background in the military and some similar
incidents, the books are widely disparate in approach, ambition, style
and content.
''Face of a Hero,'' told in the first person by a gunner named Ben
Isaacs, is a harrowing but relatively straightforward dramatic account
of one man's wartime experiences. Isaacs, nicknamed Pops because he is
older than the other members of the crew, is obsessed by his hatred of
Hitler and Fascism.
''Catch-22'' is a Dantesque vision, a darkly comic surrealistic
portrait of men caught up in the madness of war. Mr. Heller's
protagonist, Yossarian, is a bombardier who comes to believe -- with
some justification -- that everyone is trying to kill him. With an
increasing desperation, he wants to complete his 50 missions so he can
go home, but keeps finding the number of missions needed raised by his
commanding officer.
An examination of the two books leads this reader to conclude that the
similarities between the two can easily be attributed to the shared
wartime experiences of the authors. In his first chapter, for
instance, Falstein introduces his flight crew, one of whom is
identified as ''the stringy young Texan.'' Coincidentally, Mr.
Heller's first chapter is called ''The Texan'' and one of the
characters is from Texas, but the scene is entirely different.
Yossarian is in a hospital. ''It was love at first sight,'' Mr. Heller
begins. ''The first time Yossarian saw the chaplain he fell madly in
love with him.''
In that chapter, Mr. Heller introduces ''the soldier in white'' who
''was encased from head to toe in plaster and gauze.'' He continues,
''He had two useless legs and two useless arms'' and had been smuggled
into the ward at night. Later in his book, Falstein also has a soldier
in white who ''looked entombed in the cast, like an Egyptian mummy.''
This invalid is the crew's new pilot, wounded in action. In
''Catch-22,'' the figure is as mysterious and as metaphorical as the
Unknown Soldier.
In Falstein's book there is an animal lover who sleeps with five cats.
In Mr. Heller's book, there is Hungry Joe, who ''dreamed that Huple's
cat was sleeping on his face, suffocating him, and when he woke up,
Huple's cat was sleeping on his face.'' Both Isaacs and Yossarian take
extra flak jackets into combat as protection -- as apparently did
Falstein, Mr. Heller and other members of flight crews in combat. In
each book, there is a holiday party that ends in gunfire and there is
a rape scene with some similarity.
While ''Face of a Hero'' holds firmly to a realistic base,
''Catch-22'' is a transforming act of the imagination, populated by
fiercely original characters like Milo Minderbinder, the flamboyant
opportunist who bombs his own air base for profit (Falstein has a
black marketeer in his company, far smaller in scope than Milo). From
Mr. Heller, there is also Major Major Major Major, whose fate is to
look like Henry Fonda but not act anything like him. Then there is Doc
Daneeka with his theory of ''Catch-22.'' A man has to be declared
crazy to be relieved from combat duty, but ''anyone who wants to get
out of combat duty isn't really crazy.''
Falstein, who was born in Ukraine and came to the United States in
1925, wrote several other novels, including ''Slaughter Street'' and
''Sole Survivor,'' as well as a biography of Sholom Aleichem for young
readers. After the war, he attended New York University and later
taught there and at City College. He continued to write late in life
but his work was not published, his son said.
In his recent memoir, ''Now and Then,'' Mr. Heller discusses in detail
the models for some of his characters. Reviewing the book in The Times
of London, J. G. Ballard reflected on the importance of ''Catch-22,''
calling it ''the last great novel written in English.'' Paradoxically,
it was Mr. Ballard's piece that led to that questioning letter to the
editor and the subsequent controversy.
Herbert F. West reviewed it favorably in The New York Times Book
Review, calling it ''the most mature novel about the Air Force that
has yet appeared. . . . a book that is both exciting and important.''
Still, the book and its author faded into obscurity.
When Joseph Heller's ''Catch-22'' was published 11 years later,
Richard G. Stern gave it a negative review in the Times Book Review.
He said that it ''gasps for want of craft and sensibility'' and called
it ''an emotional hodgepodge.'' Despite that indictment, ''Catch-22''
eventually became a phenomenal success -- a best seller, a film and
the cornerstone of a major literary career.
Now, in a strange twist, the two books have come together, and their
meeting has led to a provocative debate. In a recent letter to The
Times of London, Lewis Pollock, a London bibliophile, wondered if
anyone could ''account for the amazing similarity of characters,
personality traits, eccentricities, physical descriptions, personnel
injuries and incidents'' in the two books.
He asked if this were ''a remarkable example of synchronicity.'' That
letter has sparked conjecture in both Britain and the United States
about the origins of ''Catch-22.'' An article appeared this week in
The Sunday Times of London, followed by one the next day on the front
page of The Washington Post suggesting that Mr. Heller may have
appropriated material from Falstein's book.
On the telephone from his home on Long Island, Mr. Heller issued a
categorical denial. He said he was influenced in his writing by
Celine, Waugh and Nabokov, but not by Falstein. ''I never read the
book,'' he said. ''I never heard of the book or the author. To the
extent that there are similarities, they are coincidences, and if the
similarities are striking then they are striking coincidences.''
He added, ''If I went through the 'Iliad' I would probably find as
many similarities to 'Catch-22' as other people seem to be finding
between Falstein's book and mine.''
Robert Gottlieb, who edited ''Catch-22'' for Simon & Schuster, was
astonished at the suggestion that Mr. Heller might have borrowed
anything from Falstein or any other writer. ''I've never seen, heard
or felt Joe Heller doing anything remotely less than honest during our
40-year relationship,'' he said. ''It is inconceivable that he used
any other writer's work. For one thing, he's too shrewd to do
something so blatant. It's easier for me to believe that Falstein
anticipated 'Catch-22.' ''
Both authors were in the Army Air Force in Europe during World War II
as members of combat crews on bombers. Falstein was stationed in
southern Italy, Mr. Heller in Corsica (called Pianosa in his book).
For each, this was a first novel. Mr. Falstein died in 1995 at 86.
While it was easy enough for Mr. Heller to be unaware of Mr.
Falstein's book, it is implausible that Falstein was unaware of
''Catch-22,'' a highly celebrated book that dealt with a closely
related subject. ''Where was Mr. Falstein between 1961 and his
death?'' asked Mr. Gottlieb. ''If he felt his book was misused, he
should have said something about it.'' Falstein's son, Joshua, who is
a court stenographer, said this week that his father never mentioned
''Catch-22'' to him.
From a reading of ''Face of a Hero'' (published by Harcourt Brace and
long out of print), it is clear that each novel stands on its own.
Despite the common background in the military and some similar
incidents, the books are widely disparate in approach, ambition, style
and content.
''Face of a Hero,'' told in the first person by a gunner named Ben
Isaacs, is a harrowing but relatively straightforward dramatic account
of one man's wartime experiences. Isaacs, nicknamed Pops because he is
older than the other members of the crew, is obsessed by his hatred of
Hitler and Fascism.
''Catch-22'' is a Dantesque vision, a darkly comic surrealistic
portrait of men caught up in the madness of war. Mr. Heller's
protagonist, Yossarian, is a bombardier who comes to believe -- with
some justification -- that everyone is trying to kill him. With an
increasing desperation, he wants to complete his 50 missions so he can
go home, but keeps finding the number of missions needed raised by his
commanding officer.
An examination of the two books leads this reader to conclude that the
similarities between the two can easily be attributed to the shared
wartime experiences of the authors. In his first chapter, for
instance, Falstein introduces his flight crew, one of whom is
identified as ''the stringy young Texan.'' Coincidentally, Mr.
Heller's first chapter is called ''The Texan'' and one of the
characters is from Texas, but the scene is entirely different.
Yossarian is in a hospital. ''It was love at first sight,'' Mr. Heller
begins. ''The first time Yossarian saw the chaplain he fell madly in
love with him.''
In that chapter, Mr. Heller introduces ''the soldier in white'' who
''was encased from head to toe in plaster and gauze.'' He continues,
''He had two useless legs and two useless arms'' and had been smuggled
into the ward at night. Later in his book, Falstein also has a soldier
in white who ''looked entombed in the cast, like an Egyptian mummy.''
This invalid is the crew's new pilot, wounded in action. In
''Catch-22,'' the figure is as mysterious and as metaphorical as the
Unknown Soldier.
In Falstein's book there is an animal lover who sleeps with five cats.
In Mr. Heller's book, there is Hungry Joe, who ''dreamed that Huple's
cat was sleeping on his face, suffocating him, and when he woke up,
Huple's cat was sleeping on his face.'' Both Isaacs and Yossarian take
extra flak jackets into combat as protection -- as apparently did
Falstein, Mr. Heller and other members of flight crews in combat. In
each book, there is a holiday party that ends in gunfire and there is
a rape scene with some similarity.
While ''Face of a Hero'' holds firmly to a realistic base,
''Catch-22'' is a transforming act of the imagination, populated by
fiercely original characters like Milo Minderbinder, the flamboyant
opportunist who bombs his own air base for profit (Falstein has a
black marketeer in his company, far smaller in scope than Milo). From
Mr. Heller, there is also Major Major Major Major, whose fate is to
look like Henry Fonda but not act anything like him. Then there is Doc
Daneeka with his theory of ''Catch-22.'' A man has to be declared
crazy to be relieved from combat duty, but ''anyone who wants to get
out of combat duty isn't really crazy.''
Falstein, who was born in Ukraine and came to the United States in
1925, wrote several other novels, including ''Slaughter Street'' and
''Sole Survivor,'' as well as a biography of Sholom Aleichem for young
readers. After the war, he attended New York University and later
taught there and at City College. He continued to write late in life
but his work was not published, his son said.
In his recent memoir, ''Now and Then,'' Mr. Heller discusses in detail
the models for some of his characters. Reviewing the book in The Times
of London, J. G. Ballard reflected on the importance of ''Catch-22,''
calling it ''the last great novel written in English.'' Paradoxically,
it was Mr. Ballard's piece that led to that questioning letter to the
editor and the subsequent controversy.
Labels:
catch-22,
joseph heller,
something interesting
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)